To refer to this article use this url: http://contributionstozoology.nl/vol67/nr02/a04


Contributions to Zoology, 67 (2) 151-154 (1997)

Short notes and reviews

The first painting of a Javan rhinoceros in Europe

Lothar Dittrich

Schulkoppel 1, D-29223, Celle-Boye, Germany

Keywords: Javan rhinoceros, Rhinoceros sondaicus,, first knowledge in Europe

Abstract


The Dutch painter Philips Angel (1616-1683) was born in Middelburg, the Netherlands, worked some time in Haarlem, but spent most of his time in his native city (Bol, 1949). He made a water-colour of the Javan one-horned rhinoceros (Rhinoceros sondaicus Desmarest, 1822). Since the painting is so lifelike, it appears to have been drawn from a living specimen. Therefore, it could represent the first specimen of this rare species that ever reached Europe alive. The water-colour, now in a private collection, is signed but not dated by the painter. The painting must have been made between the years 1630, around which time the career of Angel began, and 1658, when a woodcut of the water-colour was printed. The water-colour was published by Müllenmeister (1978) , but until now there has been no reference to it in the zoological literature dealing with the rhinoceroses in Europe. Nothing could be found in archives in the Netherlands concerning the origin and ultimate fate of that specimen of rhino.

The painting


In a recent publication, Müllenmeister (1978) discussed a number of animal illustrations by Dutch artists, mainly preserved in private collections. Among these he illustrated a water-colour of a rhinoceros by Philips Angel from Middelburg. It clearly shows a specimen of the Javan rhinoceros (Rhinoceros sondaicus Desmarest, 1822) judging from the specific arrangement of the folds in the shoulder region. Next to the rhinoceros the artist depicted two large pollard willows (Fig. 1). The landscape in the background does not give reason to believe that the rhinoceros was drawn in Asia. The water-colour is signed by the artist, but not dated. On its reverse there is a short text, in a handwriting which certainly did not belong to Angel (J. Bol, in litt., 1984): "Renosceros, is door een konstig tekenaer naer het leven afgemaelt, heeft de hoogte en grote van eenen middelbaaren olyphant" [translated: "Rhinoceros, drawn after life by a good artist, has the height and size of an average elephant"] (Müllenmeister, 1978, verified from the original in a Dutch private collection by F. F. J. M. Pieters and L. C. Rookmaaker, in litt., 1984).

FIG2

Fig. 1. Water-colour (18.3 x 23.9 cm) of a Javan rhinoceros by Philips Angel (1616-1683) of Middelburg, in a private collection in Holland.

Philips Angel was born in 1616 in the town of Middelburg in the province of Zeeland (Bol, 1949). He worked for some time in Haarlem, but he returned to Middelburg at the time of his marriage in 1642 and died there in 1683. Philips Angel never left Holland, certainly never traveled to Asia, although there was a contemporary namesake who did.

The art historian J. Bol (in litt., 1984) could not give any indication about the date of this water-colour. A stylistic comparison with other works by the artist is impossible as Angel left only one water-colour and no drawings or sketches.

However, it is certain that this water-colour of the Javan rhinoceros was drawn before 1658, because an almost identical woodcut of the same animal was published in a posthumous book by Jacob Bontius “Historiae Naturalis et Medicae Indiae Orientalis”, edited by Gulielmus Piso and printed in Amsterdam in 1658 (Fig. 2). It is safe to assume that the woodcut was made after this water-colour. In a footnote to the text by Bontius, Piso did not actually mention Angel as the artist responsible for this picture which he obtained in Amsterdam, but he suggested that it was “in Indiis depictam” ("drawn in India"; Piso in Bontius, 1658: 52). Presumably he did not know either the original of the woodcut published in the book or its artist.

FIG2

Fig. 2. Woodcut after the water-colour shown in Fig. 1, published in Bontius (1658: 51) and reproduced in its original size.

The rhinoceros depicted in Angel‘s water-colour is not mentioned in the zoological literature dealing with the rhinoceroses seen in Europe (Noll, 1873; Gowers, 1952; Sody, 1959; Reynolds, 1960; Kourist, 1970; Rookmaaker, 1973; and Clarke, 1986). Investigations in Dutch archives, for instance in the archives of the city of Middelburg, where various animals were exhibited in the townhall after 1660 (Engel, 1939), have not yet produced any evidence about the importation or exhibition of a Javan rhinoceros in Holland in the years between 1630, when Philips Angel started to paint, and 1658, when the woodcut of the animal appeared in the book by Jacob Bontius.

Houtzager (1979) found evidence that on 13 October 1662 the Theatrum Anatomicum in Delft received a mounted rhinoceros as a gift from the local representatives of the East India Company. Its specific identity is not recorded. The specimen was first exhibited in Delft for five years, after which it was lent out to two businessmen from Amsterdam for show on local fairs.

In 1672, Holger Jacobaeus saw a mounted rhinoceros on a ship in Amsterdam (Maar, 1910: 27). No further evidence has come to light.

We cannot decide, therefore, if the specimens in Delft and Amsterdam were in fact one and the same, if one or two specimens of the rhinoceros were imported in Holland during that period of the 17th century, if one or two rhinoceroses died on the way to Holland or maybe that one or both animals actually were alive on arrival to be mounted after their death. As it is not known to which species of rhinoceros these mounted specimens belonged, it cannot be decided if the rhinoceros depicted in the water-colour by Angel, unknown from other sources, in fact died soon after the artist saw it, was mounted and later was exhibited in Delft and possibly in Amsterdam.

Thus, we publish here the oldest known illustration of a Rhinoceros sondaicus, painted by Philips Angel somewhere between 1630 and 1658, which probably represents the first specimen of a Javan rhinoceros that ever reached Europe alive (Fig. 1).

References


Bol, L.J., 1949. Philips Angel van Middelburg en Philips Angel van Leiden. Oud-Holland, 64: 3-19 (reprint Nendeln, 1976).

Bontius, J., 1658. Historiae naturalis & medicae Indiae Orientalis liber quintus, de Quadrupedibus, Avibus, & Piscibus. In: G. Piso (ed.), De Indiae utriusque re naturali et medica libri quatuordecim: 50-86 (apud L. & D. Elzevirios, Amstelaedami).

Clarke, T.H., 1986. The rhinoceros from Dürer to Stubbs, 1515-1799: 1-219 (Sotheby’s Publications, London).

Engel, H., 1939. Alphabetical list of Dutch zoological cabinets and menageries. Bijdr. Dierk., 27: 247-346.

[Second, enlarged edition prepared by P. Smit, A.P.M. Sanders & J.P.F. de Veer, 1986: Hendrik Engel’s alphabetical list of Dutch zoological cabinets and menageries. Nieuwe Nederlandse Bijdragen tot de Geschiedenis der Geneeskunde en der Natuurwetenschappen, 19: [i-iv], i-x, 1-340, pls. 1-21 (Rodopi, Amsterdam).]

Gowers, W., 1952. Early rhinoceroses in Europe. Country Life, London, 111 (Feb. 1952): 288-289.

Houtzager, H.L., 1979. Dieren in Delft. Tijdschr. Geschiedenis Geneesk. Natuurw. Wiskunde Techniek, 2 (2): 52-61.

Kourist, W., 1970. Die ersten einhörnigen Nashörner (Rhinoceros sondaicus Desmarest 1822 und Rhinoceros unicornis L., 1758) der großen europäischen Zoologischen Gärten in der Malerei des 19. Jahrhunderts. Zool. Beitr., (N.F.) 16 (1): 141-154.

Maar, V., 1910. Holger Jacobaeus’ Reisebog (1671-1692): [i-v], (I-XV), 1-186 (Gyldendalske Boghandel / Nordisk Forlag, København).

Müllenmeister, K.J., 1978. Meer und Land im Licht des 17. Jahrhunderts. Band 2. Tierdarstellungen in Werken niederländischer Künstler A - M: 17, Abb. 1 (Carl Schünemann Verlag, Bremen).

Noll, F.C., 1873. Die Rhinoceros-Arten (I.). Zool. Garten, 14 (1): 47-55.

Reynolds, R.J., 1960. Asian rhinos in captivity. Int. Zoo Yearb., 2: 17-42.

Rookmaaker, L.C., 1973. Rhinoceroses in Europe from 1500 until 1810. Bijdr. Dierk., 43 (1): 39-63.

Sody, H.J.V., 1959. Das Javanische Nashorn, Rhinoceros sondaicus. Z. Säugetierk., 24: 109-240.

Acknowledgements


I thank Kees Rookmaaker for the translation of my text and Mrs. Florence F. J. M. Pieters for referring to the bibliography about the exhibition of a mounted rhinoceros specimen in Amsterdam, and both of them for a critical discussion about the possible origin of the Javan rhinoceros, painted by Philips Angel.